Home Learning: King John

Subject: History | Year: 7

Estimated Time: 30-40 Minutes

Name: _________________________ Class/Set: ____________ Due Date: ____________

The Purpose

Why are we doing this? To evaluate the reign of King John by applying historical evidence to understand why he faced a rebellion from his barons, leading to the signing of the Magna Carta.

Instructions

1. Retrieve: List three specific problems King John faced during his reign. Consider his relationship with the Church, his wars in France, and his treatment of the English barons.

2. Analyse: Complete the "Barons' Grievances" table below. For each action taken by King John, explain why it made the barons angry.

King John's Action	Why did he do it?	Why did this upset the Barons?
High Taxes	To pay for wars in France.
The Interdict	An argument with the Pope.
Losing Land	Defeat by King Philip II.

3. Draft: Write a single, high-quality paragraph (6-8 sentences) answering the following question: "Was King John a 'bad' king or just an 'unlucky' king?"
   • Model: Use the 'PEEL' structure (Point, Evidence, Explanation, Link).
   • Explain: Use evidence such as the nickname 'Softsword', his argument with Pope Innocent III, or the heavy 'Scutage' (shield money) taxes he demanded.

Success Criteria (Checklist)

• ☐ I have identified three major problems faced by King John.
• ☐ I have explained how John’s actions impacted his relationship with the barons.
• ☐ I have used the PEEL structure in my summary paragraph.
• ☐ I have used Tier 3 historical terms (e.g., Interdict, Excommunication, Scutage, Magna Carta).

Challenge / Extension (Optional)

• Research: Find out what the 'Magna Carta' actually means in Latin and identify one specific clause from the document that still impacts British law today.

---

⚠ TEACHER’S GUIDANCE & MARK SCHEME (DO NOT PRINT FOR STUDENTS)

---

Teacher’s Post-Task Briefing 🎓

1. Model Answers / Expected Outcomes

• Task 1 (Retrieve): Students should identify: 1. Loss of Normandy/land in France. 2. Argument with the Pope (Innocent III) over the Archbishop of Canterbury. 3. High taxes/Scutage.
• Task 2 (Analysis Table):
  • High Taxes: Barons felt John was draining their wealth for unsuccessful wars.
  • The Interdict: The Pope banned church services in England; barons feared for their souls and resented John’s excommunication.
  • Losing Land: Earned him the nickname 'Softsword'; barons felt he was a weak military leader compared to his brother, Richard the Lionheart.
• Task 3 (PEEL Paragraph): A 'Greater Depth' answer will acknowledge that while John was cruel (e.g., the mystery of Prince Arthur), he also inherited huge debts from Richard I’s Crusades and faced a very strong French King, suggesting a mix of 'bad' character and 'unlucky' circumstances.

2. Common Misconceptions to Flag 🚩

• The Magna Carta was for everyone: Students often think the Magna Carta gave rights to all English people. Explain: It was originally designed to protect the rights of the Barons (the elite), not the 'ordinary' peasants.
• John was the only 'bad' King: Ensure students understand that many kings were ruthless; John’s failure was largely his inability to manage the 'political nation' (the nobles) effectively.

3. Classroom Discussion Starters (The 'Journey') 🗣️

• The Power Balance: If King John had won his wars in France, would the Barons ever have forced him to sign the Magna Carta?
• Modern Links: Why do we still talk about a piece of parchment from 1215 in modern British politics? (Link to British Values: The Rule of Law).