Lesson: Pompeii
Year: 7 | Subject: History | Time Allocation: 100%
Class/Set: ____________ Date/Term: ____________
LO (WALT): To explain how Pompeii serves as a historical source for understanding Roman society and to evaluate the reliability of archaeological evidence.
Success Criteria (WILF):
- I can identify different types of archaeological evidence found at Pompeii (e.g., frescoes, graffiti, carbonised remains).
- I can use the PEE (Point, Evidence, Explanation) structure to explain what artefacts reveal about Roman daily life.
- I can evaluate the limitations of Pompeii as a 'perfect' snapshot of the Roman world.
1. Starter (15%)
- Analyse: Display a high-resolution image of a carbonised loaf of bread found at Pompeii.
- Discuss: Ask students to identify the object and suggest why it was preserved so perfectly while most Roman food has rotted away.
- Identify: Introduce the term 'carbonisation' and explain how the ash from Mount Vesuvius (AD 79) created a unique archaeological seal.
2. Main Activity (70%)
Teacher Input:
- Contextualise: Explain the eruption of Mount Vesuvius and the subsequent burial of Pompeii and Herculaneum.
- Define: Introduce 'Archaeology' as the study of physical remains and 'Primary Sources' as contemporary evidence.
- Display: Show three key areas of evidence: the House of the Vettii (wealth and frescoes), the Fullery of Stephanus (work and industry), and the Forum (politics and religion).
- Model: Demonstrate a PEE paragraph on the board: "Point: Romans valued social status. Evidence: We see large, ornate frescoes in the atrium of the House of the Vettii. Explanation: This suggests that wealthy Romans used their homes to impress guests and display their riches."
- Facilitate: Discuss the 'Reliability' of the site. Ask: "Is Pompeii a normal Roman town, or is it biased because it only shows us one specific moment in time?"
Student Task:
| Evidence Type |
What it Reveals About Society |
Reliability Rating (1-5) |
| Political Graffiti |
Democracy and local elections |
4 |
| Garden Statues |
Religious beliefs and leisure |
3 |
| Slave Quarters |
Social hierarchy and inequality |
5 |
- Complete: Students use the 'Evidence Analysis' table above to categorise findings from provided source packs (Teacher-provided: Source Pack A).
- Write: Respond to the following prompt using the PEEL structure: "How useful is Pompeii for a historian trying to understand the lives of ordinary Romans?"
- Support: Provide a list of Tier 3 vocabulary (e.g., fresco, atrium, forum, stratigraphy, in situ) for students to include in their writing.
- Challenge: Ask 'Greater Depth' students to consider how the 18th-century excavations might have damaged or altered the evidence we see today.
3. Plenary (15%)
- Consolidate: Conduct a 'Hinge Question' MCQ to check understanding of archaeological reliability.
- Debate: "If a disaster struck our town today and it was buried for 2,000 years, what one object would you want archaeologists to find to understand your life?"
- Summarise: Reiterate that while Pompeii is an incomparable source, historians must cross-reference physical evidence with written accounts (like Pliny the Younger) to get a full picture.
4. Resources
- Image of carbonised bread (Digital).
- Source Pack A: Selected images of Pompeii frescoes, graffiti, and floor plans.
- Evidence Analysis Table (Worksheet).
- Mini-whiteboards for the Hinge Question.
⚠ TEACHER’S GUIDANCE
💡 Pedagogical Insights
- Year 7 Transition: This lesson serves as a bridge from the descriptive history of Key Stage 2 to the more analytical requirements of Key Stage 3. Ensure students understand that 'evidence' requires 'interpretation'—it doesn't speak for itself.
- Misconception Alert: Students often believe everyone in Pompeii died. Remind them that many escaped; archaeology primarily shows us the structures and those who stayed behind.
- Archaeological Ethics: If using images of plaster casts, ensure a respectful tone, as these represent the final moments of real individuals (Safeguarding/SMSC).
🔑 Answer Key & Task Solutions
Task: Evidence Analysis Table
- Political Graffiti Answer: Reveals that local elections were competitive and that ordinary citizens (and even women, via proxy) were involved in supporting candidates.
- Garden Statues Answer: Reveals the importance of Greek influence on Roman art and the domestic worship of gods (Lares).
- Slave Quarters Answer: Reveals the stark contrast in living conditions; even in wealthy villas, slaves lived in cramped, dark, and undecorated spaces.
Task: PEEL Writing Prompt (Model Answer)
- Point: Pompeii is highly useful for understanding ordinary Roman lives because it preserves 'in situ' (in place) items that usually decay.
- Evidence: For example, the discovery of amphorae (storage jars) and graffiti in local taverns shows us what people ate and drank.
- Explanation: In most Roman cities, these items are lost; at Pompeii, the ash preserved the 'common' parts of life, not just the history of Emperors.
- Link: Therefore, it is the most significant source we have for the social history of the 1st Century AD.
Plenary: Hinge Question (MCQ)
- Question: Why might a historian say Pompeii is a 'biased' source?
- a) ☐ The volcano destroyed all the important evidence.
- b) ☐ It only represents a single moment in time rather than the whole of Roman history.
- c) ☐ There are no written records left in the city.
- d) ☐ The Romans hid their best treasures before the eruption.
- Correct Answer: b) ☐ It only represents a single moment in time rather than the whole of Roman history.